WillfulWren
Rawr XD
Just some characters for RP and writing I'd like reviewed.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature currently requires accessing the site using the built-in Safari browser.
I'm working on it, I just haven't really outlined some of these guys in character sheet form, and they're being little brats about being describedWell, we can't give any feedback without the actual characters here
My only real issue is with the backstory. It seems far too over the top and overdramatic, seeming to jump from one tragedy to the next without proper connection between them or benefit for the characterization as a whole. It's fine for the characters to have issues in their lives, but be careful not be excessive, as you will write yourself into a corner where you can't really raise the stakes and where it becomes difficult for other characters to properly interact with you because it becomes hard to take them seriously by contrast with the horrible tragedy yours is, and by consequence your own character becomes hard to take seriously. Good tragedy is always in the downfall, and where there is too much of a fall, people start taking the bottomlessness as a joke.
Beyond that, the backstory doesn't seem to be oriented, this is, there isn't a particular direction that it seems to want to go to. I guess this is fine since this OC isn't built for a specific RP or story, but simply "in the air" but still that's something you may want to keep in mind.
As for the rest, I would have appreciated to have a list of skills, powers, magic, items that kind of stuff, since that tends to be pretty relevant. The personality was nice, but I do recommend adding a little more humanity to it, try naming some more specific interests and tastes that do not particularly relate to what she is.
While I applaud you for having in-character justifications, a lot of those read like soap opera plotting to an outside view- the visible impact on the actual characterization. It doesn't seem like you're giving the tragedy any more reason than adding tragedy, you're making the character miserable for the sake of them being miserable, and even that much is not really showing on the character's present state. for example, her abandoment seems like throw-out prejudice. It doesn't seem to have a big impact on the character as it is, and it's a shitty way to treat someone for no reason at all (as the whole eye-color thing is nothing anyone can get behind) so the result is you just tortured a character we were supposed to care about, rewards zero and meaning zero. If anything, that bit of backstory just destroyed our encounter with an entire culture of witches and someone that inhabited and grew up in said culture.Thanks for the input! I mainly try to have reasons for the tragedy - Calianthe was abandoned due to being a witch because her love interest had some witch blood that didn't even give him any magic, just made his eyes golden, so no one would hire him for a job and he ended up on the streets, and she broke down because it was established from the start that she was a 'weak' character, who always had to be looked after and protected by her big sister. They didn't get help because Karina was messing with the fabric of their universe - which was a thing that was a thing long before where Clarisse being her niece fitted into things was even thought of.
Heck, Kari's been messing with stuff she shouldn't be messing with before half my characters were even made. Erebus is an overall asshat, who found enjoyment in torturing people, and after Kari dismissed his feelings for her, he went for one of the two people she cared about. And the other Ancients, pretty much the only friends Clarisse has managed to keep for a long amount of time because of her overall abrasiveness, had to die because they were too much of a 'flight risk ' to live, and Isabel, the new queen, knew full well how untrustworthy Clarisse is, and wanted to see how easily Clarisse could be manipulated, or what she would do to survive.
"Kill him or i kill you" works pretty well because Clarisse is a coward.
Oh boy be careful with that one. Mind control is really OP if not given proper limitations, not to mention a drag to deal with if your partner or worse, if your enemy just so happens to be vulnerable to it.As a SirenSinger - a subset of vampires - she can compel humans with her voice.
Oh boy be careful with that one. Mind control is really OP if not given proper limitations, not to mention a drag to deal with if your partner or worse, if your enemy just so happens to be vulnerable to it.
Sorry about the harshness, I take my criticisms very seriously.
I don't know if you're into anime at all, but for any mind-control subjects, code geass and in particular the character Lelouch vi Brittania are excellent examples of mind contorl limitations done right. Just for future referenceThere are (obviously) limitations. The only characters I have that are like seriously overpowered are the Spirits, and they're literal embodiements of things like "Earth" and "Fire" so they literally control all that is that thing. Sirensingers can compel not control. Those with a strong mind can probably resist them, and it takes a heck ton of concentration for the vampire, and often gives them a headache....
I see. Well, you should have it written down fully at least, even if you don't reveal it. As a writer, roleplaying or writing stories, you're gonna sometimes find yourself in situations where you want really badly to tweak this or that about your character. If you ever heard the word "contrived", well, that's how those situations come to be. With experience writers learn to tweak details in more organic manners, but I would recommend trying to stick to a solid character and not changing that solid frama beyond natural character growth, until you have really mastered doing thatAnd that's the only point I can argue. Her backstory probably isn't going to be revealed fully in the story she's in, it just...Exists, as a kind of reason why she's the way she is, to help me figure out how she'd react to some situations.
....She's not really the sort to open up about stuff.
Tip: A good tragedy is tragic not in the middle but in the conclusion. You WANT to contrast the bad parts with good parts. A parade of terrible stuff is nothing compared to the power of a girl who carried a cherished teddy bear all the way to her adult years, only to loose it by accident in a cruiseship and desperately coming to the realization that she will never see the bear that carried her fond memories again now that the ship has sailed and cannot return. It's a simple, yet potentially more effective story, because the tragedy only works as well as the weight of the stakes you've set before the tragedy itself began,And it's okay, serious is good! I do need to work on the issue of me giving all my favourite character's horrifyingly tragic backstories
I love anime, and Code Geass has been in my list for like three years but I've never quite got round to it...I don't know if you're into anime at all, but for any mind-control subjects, code geass and in particular the character Lelouch vi Brittania are excellent examples of mind contorl limitations done right. Just for future reference
I really recommend giving it a watch.I love anime, and Code Geass has been in my list for like three years but I've never quite got round to it...
I would, but I'm currently watching Katekyo Hitman RebornI really recommend giving it a watch
No one said it had to be right now lolI would, but I'm currently watching Katekyo Hitman Reborn