Yggjar
Magic Eight Ball
See you are thinking about rp from a competitive standpoint as opposed to a narrative stand point, you forget that RP really isn't about fighting it's about the story, sure we have fun and fights are cool but that's not what it's about. I trust that these people understand that.
2
Honestly, it all comes down to moderation, that much is true. But even coming from a Narration Standpoint these abilities are "potential" problems unless well moderated and trusting players that barely have anything in their CS is something I wouldn't do. And if you think that story of yours will live without any conflict, whether against NPC's or against a player then what I've said before just became that much truer. At least you're going to change something about the abilities.
3. I know exactly what @Wickedkent and @Melinoe Dark can do. How do I know? Because they came to me and talked to me about their abilities and I helped them with it. I can tell you for a fact that @Melinoe Dark does not have every power in Tarot Mimicry and she has actually nerfed herself to a great degree even from what we both talked about and I don't care if she wrote 3 words that's no reason to be rude to her about how she decided to make her CS. I can tell you for a fact that @Wickedkent is not nearly as OP as you think he is because we talked about it and at the end of the day, knowing the future does not guarantee you can change it.
6
Well, as a player that would be involved in the RP the CS doesn't tell me anything about her ability. And if you think that is rude for me to point out, that there is barely any information, then maybe you should honestly think about how it looks from the outside. I think hiding abilities can be interesting but it wouldn't hurt to point out in the CS Thread itself, that way people would know it's at least moderated to some degree. This still doesn't change that a one liner for your supercharge ability is laughable, especially if it's an ability like hers. You throw around rude a lot, but it is an honest critic of her CS and it seems that your only defense for defending call outs of low-quality Character Sheets is "You're Rude!", yeah, that seems quite rude in itself.
Anyway, I fairly critiqued about what I was concerned about and whether you think it's rude or not, at the end of the day doesn't really matter all that much. I must apologize about the doomed to fail part because that certainly was going a bit too far in retrospect. I don't know you and your moderation capabilities, so I shouldn't have made that one comment.
Alright, I wish you the best of luck in that project and hope you didn't take anything I've said as a personal attack on yourself.
Last edited by a moderator: