It depends on the GM and what they expect.
If that was posted in a roleplay that I was GMing. No the smaller post would not be acceptable.
But then again, that's my standards. And trust me I have seen fight scenes where every single post in the fight scene was as long... If not longer than...
Levels of roleplay.
One liner: one sentence to a paragraph.
Casual: two to three paragraphs.
Detailed: three to five and up.
As of the question, does a paragraph count as a post.. yes in a onliner roleplay.
In casual and higher levels... it is seen as a one liner... Due to the levels of...
He even stated that he won't read detailed posts because he finds them boring.
So if I wanted to really express my character he would just skim the post and then post his paragraph. To me that's mean and insulting. As a role player I have my own style and I choose to rp and share that style...
He stated that detail doesn't mater and that it was a waist of time....
So he put my style down first... how is that any different from what I have stated?
What makes a post a good post?
It's opinion over fact because everyone is different and has their own taste and style in how they like their role plays.
If you find my opinion insulting or you think I am making fun of you report me. I never called you names or even said a curse word or nothing.
I didn't like the post because if I was rping with you I would have to pick up the extra slack in making the rp enjoyable for me too. Rps have two or...
You never made this a friendly debate. Starting up a thread was you trying to find others to help you argue your opinion. Meanwhile those in the rp where this topic counts all voted for longer posts.
You stated that long posts are boring. I like long posts and I post them... yet I found no...
Please report me for expressing myself. There are levels in rping. One liners, casual and detailed.
Excuse me for you reading things out of context. I only stated that I have to hold back on my creativity due to a small post that I felt was lacking.
Or the fact that I was merely asking what...
I could respond to that.... but then I would feel like I would have to drop to your level of response for that post... I don't think it's fair that I have to dull down my creativity to your level. If I want quality and quality I find rpers like me.
If I want to dull down my responses and not...
To me they were both lacking. If I got that as a response I would drop the rp. To me that's the other person saying... I don't care in character development or story development. Why was he there? What is he trying to do? I'm not sure it doesn't say...
Excuse me for wanting to have quality and quantity in responses to my posts.
To me these are all one liners that I feel cheated out of good quality work.
Yes, I never asked for a novel, but I do like detail and post I can really get into.
In my opinion... again stating what I prefer.. I would rather have the long post response then the lesser half.
When you hand in an essay do you hand in a paragraph? Or a fully essay expressing how you feel or even stating the facts on the subject?