Myling
A succesful failure
Right! I actually like application based method more, too. Even though I probably didn't sound like it lol. But I think its neat that instead of who is the fastest, your skills and creativity determines whether you get accepted ^^i believe the biggest reason why gm's might not accept characters without giving them the opportunity to edit is when there are limited slots. i see this most often (and find it the most relevant!) with roleplays that have fixed roles that characters should fall into, where the character count has already been predetermined. otherwise, gm's may just want to keep the group on a smaller scale. it's obviously not for everyone and it sucks getting rejected, but as someone who prefers this system i think the reasoning is quite sound! (^▽^)
of course there are always those who don't fall under these categories and inexplicably reject applications in roleplays that may not require selection, but i believe this is the thought process most gm's who run application-based roleplays have. hopefully that helps you understand it a little better! ٩(。•́‿•̀。)۶
and to avoid digressing completely:
funnily enough, even though i would say my first brush with roleplay was on instagram (book fandom kids,,, you know the drill), i can't recall myself having an actual one-liner phase like i see some mention, and i transitioned into ocs quite quickly despite getting into roleplay via fandoms ( ´ ω ` ) it's surprising to say, but the more i think about it the more similarities my brief time on instagram has with my current experience on rpn! Σ(°ロ°)
i also see a ton of people talking about the coding and i cannot agree enough! that was probably the biggest difference for me, though mostly because the old sites i had been on weren't forums and didn't quite allow for coding. when i was on instagram, designing cses and aesthetics was totally a thing though, so i guess i wasn't always as far off as i thought! considering i had no prior experience w/ coding and only learnt bbcode because i thought accordions were cool, i think i've come a really long way (o˘◡˘o)
I just didn't know it was a thing, so i was little surprised when I first noticed it~