Sure! I'll give it a few episodes and get back to you. I'm not a huge fan of horror myself, but I can get Lovecraftian horror or things along that vein. I'm not not into gore and jumpscares since I'm squeamish lol
Pokemon Reborn just 'updated' to Episode 19, which is supposed to be the last episode. It's still in beta but it's open-access and since I played the game a very long time ago I've picked it back up to get a fresh experience with all the new updates.
A fellow Trash Taste Enjoyer! I think they're the only podcast I listen to just to kill time xD
The other podcasts I listen to are usually educational and usually historical, like the History of England podcast that I got into through ExtraCredits.
I'm pretty sure my first anime was one of the usual picks...Naruto, Dragon Ball Z, or Pokemon. Couldn't tell you which one it was, but it was definitely one of those.